Something New

“Hurry up, hurry up, hurry up...”

Damn, it’s cold tonight. Whatever surprise you’ve got for me better be worth schlepping seven blocks in the snow...

“Hey, come on in.”

“Mmm, you’re warm.”

“So…you’ve got a special surprise for me, huh?”

“Indeed I do. Do you trust me?”

“Of course I do.”

You flash a cheeky smile at me. Not giving away any details, huh? That’s not surprising. I swiped left on you on two different apps. And then we ran into each other… where was it? At some natural wine bar downtown, I think. You were different in person than online. I didn’t want to like you, probably because I thought I was following my gut.

But…you charmed me. And here we are, three months later. Neither of us are looking for anything serious, so I wouldn’t call you my boyfriend or anything, but…you’re definitely more than just a booty call. And our relationship is centered almost entirely around sex.

“Here, let me get that.”

You hang my coat on the hook on the wall and pull me into your arms. Your beard scrapes up against my cheek as we kiss.

I reluctantly pull away and turn to head to your comfy leather couch in the living room.

“Oh, um...hi.”

There’s someone sitting on your couch. Someone I’ve never seen before. I glance back at you and you’re all smiles. Something is up.

“Hey, there.”

I thought you and I were going to be spending tonight alone, but…I guess not.

“This is my friend, Paolo. We met a couple of years ago at that fellowship in Toronto I told you about.”

“Hi, nice to meet you.”

I have no idea what’s going on. But, whatever. I’ll go with it. I definitely thought the surprise you had for me was going to be…I don’t know, a Hitachi magic wand, or some CBD lube or something. Not…Paolo.

“Are you, um, visiting from out of town?”

“Yeah, yeah, I’m here to give a talk at the state capitol. Just thought I’d pop in and visit my guy. ”

You and him exchange knowing grins. Is Paolo in on this so-called surprise as well? Whether he is or not, he’s got this haughty air about him. Like that shit-eating grin is permanently stuck to his face. I give you a look. A look that says ‘what the hell is going on and I thought I was here to have sex.’

“So, babe, um…you know how we’ve been talking about…that thing you’ve been wanting to do?”

That thing? What the hell are you talking about? I search your eyes for an answer and your gaze ticks over to Paolo. Are you talking about...oh my god. I look over at Paolo. It’s ironic that I’m sitting in between the two of them.

“You’re talking about…?”

“A threesome.Yeah. You said you’ve always wanted to try it. ”

“Are you being serious...?”

“You said you...wanted to try…double penetration, right? ”

My body flushes with heat as that mental picture comes to my mind. It’s absolutely been a fantasy of mine for…basically as long as I can remember. I’ve probably masturbated to some version of that hundreds of times. I glance over at Paolo, this guy I’ve never met before, this complete stranger. How would it feel to have his cock up inside of me? The fact that he’s a stranger makes it that much more exciting.

“Keep talking...”

“I, uh, got tested right before I came into town. All clear. ”

“But, of course, there’s no pressure at all. We’re down if you are. But, we’re also totally fine with just hanging out. ”

I look back and forth between you both. He’s cute. Strong jaw, spends-all-his-free-time-in-the-gym type. Yeah, I would definitely fuck him.

“Okay, yeah. ”

“You’re sure? I promise, it’s totally fine if we do this another night...”

“Yeah, I'm in.”

You bite down on your lip and give me that look. That look I saw from across the bar the first time we met. That look you give me when you can’t think of anything but fucking me. I lean over and kiss you...

You turn your body towards mine on the couch and tangle your fingers at the back of my head. I break our kiss for just a moment to look over at Paolo. He’s attentive, watching us kiss with a hand hovering just a couple of inches away from his cock. I lay my free hand on his thigh and give it a small squeeze, letting him know he can join in when he wants. You push your tongue between my lips.

I normally like being the one in control during sex. I’m nervous - but it’s a good kind of nervous...like making my way up to the top of a roller coaster kind of nervous. Having you and Paolo’s attention fully on me is...it’s different. It’s really hot.

Your cock is pressing up against your pants…you’re getting hard already. I drift my hand down and palm it.

“Fuck…”

I break away from our kiss and drift slowly towards Paolo. I look over at him and suddenly there’s this…intensity in the room. I like the way it feels to be looked at by him. He leans forward and kisses me. He tastes like smoke and something sweet…cherries, maybe?

I massage his thigh a little harder, inching my hand up towards his hip. Fuck, this is…exciting. A complete stranger…kissing me in front of you. I lean forward and push Paolo back until he’s reclining against the armrest. I press my body against his and his arm snakes around my hips. Behind me, your cock rubs up against my ass. Fuck, I can’t wait to have your cock. If it was a little awkward at first, it’s definitely not anymore.

I kiss Paolo hard and rock my hips into his while your hands drift up and down my body. I struggle to quickly unbutton his shirt.

“I can't get them...”

“Here, I've got it.”

I lift up my own shirt and toss it to the floor. I reach for one of your hands and bring it across my bare chest. You fingers find my nipple and squeeze. Paolo’s managed to get his shirt open and I lean forward to kiss his chest.

“Seems like you like to be on top, hm?”

“Mmmhm...”

“She definitely does.”

Your other hand reaches around and you slowly undo the button of my jeans.

“Maybe I let you two take the reins tonight…”

“Oh yeah? Sit up for us.”

Oh, I like this new side of you. You’ve never really told me what to do before. When I sit up, Paolo slides out from under me and gets rid of his clothes. You keep one hand teasing my nipple while the other drifts further and further down. You pull my jeans down and I get up for a moment to kick them off. I lean back into you and turn my head to meet your lips.

Your fingers play at the edge of my underwear. You tease me over the thin fabric. Fuck.

“You like that, hm?”

“Oh fuck, yeah. That feels good...”

Paolo joins us on the couch again, completely naked now. I reach for him and pull him close until his hips are flush with mine. He draws his hand down his shaft a few times and it springs up between us. I love being pinned between you both. With you behind me, kissing down my neck and shoulders…and Paolo sucking on my nipples.

I grind up against both of you, arching my back as your fingers finally make contact with my clit.

“Fuck, fuck...”

I wrap my hand around Paolo’s cock and trace the head with my thumb.

“Oh, keep going.”

“Like that?”

“Yeah, just like that.”

“How do you want us to fuck you?”

“You tell me. You're the ones in charge.”

“You think you can fit both of us? I want to see you take us both. ”

“Try me.”

“Yeah? You ready, babe? You want us both to fuck you? ”

“Yes, please.”

You pull my underwear down to my knees. I bend forward a little and your finger rubs against my asshole...

“Yeah, baby. Yeah...”

You slide your finger into me, slowly, gently...stretching my asshole, pumping in and out. Your cock presses up against me and you slowly…slide…in.

“Oh, yes. Slow like that. Oh god!”

I rock back and forth a little and my asshole pulses around your cock. God, it feels so good just to be filled up by you.

“Good job. Think you can take one more? ”

“Yeah, yeah. Paolo, do it.”

His cock glides through my pussy, just teasing me. I rock my clit against the head of his cock and every little movement sends crippling pleasure through me.

“Yeah? Can you take it? How bad do you want it? ”

“Yes, please. Yes! So bad...”

Oh my fucking god. Fuck...both of them...inside me.

“Fuck, oh yeah...”

Behind me, you pump your hips, slowly, sliding just a couple of inches in and out of my ass.

“Am I tight, babe? Does that feel fucking good? ”

I can't...I can't take this much longer. I can't...oh, my god. Oh my god!

“Yeah, right there! That's it, don't stop. Don't stop. I'm gonna...oh, my god - I'm gonna cum. Keep going, keep going...”

“Yeah, come on, come on...”

“Oh my god, yeah. Yeah...”

You pull out of me first. Then, Paolo. I drop face down into your lap and lay my feet in Paolo’s lap as we settle back onto the couch.

“Shit. Um, wow.”

“Yeah, wow.”

“So...Paolo - how long are you in town for?”

“I head out tomorrow morning, actually.”

“I might be speaking for myself here, but…I think you should stay a little longer.”

“Yeah? Pretty safe to say there’s nowhere else I’d rather be right now.”

“Me neither.”