Not So Silent Night

“Talia! I think the latkes are burning…”

“Shit, shit, shit.”

My hands are full as I run down to the kitchen from upstairs. I drop the gifts onto the dining room table and run to the stove as fast as I can.

“Are they ruined?”

“No. I mean, I like them crispy, anyway...”

“Hey. Baby. Relax. Everything is perfect. The kids are going to love it. ”

Kate wraps her arms around my waist and I feel her chin resting against my shoulder. I turn my head and kiss her cheek. Her touch always calms me. I guess I am feeling a little tense. My ex-wife should be here any minute with our kids. We all get along quite well, despite Audrey being my ex and Kate being my girlfriend. Really well, actually. But it still sometimes makes me a little nervous when the three of us are together. Like, I don’t know how to act around the both of them. I care so deeply about those two. I’ve had such meaningful relationships with them and in those relationships, there has always been very intense sexual chemistry and connection. Audrey and I had a great marriage and two beautiful kids, but… things change. People change and drift apart. We do our best to co-parent and give the kids two stable loving homes, and I know that we’re better off as friends - but sometimes it’s hard to forget all of the amazing times we had together.

“Knock knock.”

I look up and…there she is. She’s wearing that black denim jacket she loves and a plain white shirt underneath. She’s holding both of our twins, one on each hip, both asleep.

“Hey. They passed out on the car ride here. I’ll go tuck them in real quick. ”

I smile at the sight of them and nod for her to take them upstairs.

“Well, so much for the Hanukkah celebration with the kids, huh? More latkes for us. ”

“Yeah, I guess they can open their gifts in the morning, they’ve had such a long day already I’m sure.”

“Hey. Sorry I couldn’t keep them awake. Grandma kept them busy making cookies all day. ”

“It’s okay. Don’t worry about it.”

I’m a little sad that the kids are sleeping through the last night of the holiday, but I know there’ll be plenty more opportunities to celebrate in the years to come.

“Hey, Audrey, we made way too much food. Why don’t you stick around for a bit? ”

Audrey’s eyes meet mine, just for a second, as if silently asking if it’s okay for her to stay.

“Yeah, that’d be great, why don’t you stay?”

“Yeah, why not? Thanks.”

Kate and Audrey meander towards the living room and drop down onto the sofa. It’s so funny watching them together. There’s never any jealousy between them and never any awkward silences, either. In fact, they’ve got kind of a bromance going on.

“Have you been to the new soccer stadium yet?”

“Nah, not yet. I’ve been meaning to, though. Have you? ”

“Yes, it was absolutely amazing. My company took all of us to the opening game. Now I’m thinking about getting season tickets. ”

I watch them from the kitchen for a few moments before following. They’re each sitting on the ends of the couch, leaving the middle as the only open space. As I sit down, my knee brushes up against Audrey’s. A flurry of warmth rushes through me. I quickly pull away and reach for Kate’s hand.

“Talia, you seem stressed.”

“No, no, I just…holidays, you know. They’re always exhausting.” ”

“Let me see. You’ve probably got a ton of knots in your back, again. Come here. ”

I turn my back to Kate and she presses her thumbs into my shoulder blades.

“Ohhh…god, that feels good. Kate gives the best massages - did you know she actually used to study massage therapy? ”

“No, I had no idea. That’s cool.”

I pull away from Kate’s touch and slide off of the couch.

“Babe, you have to show her. Her hands are like magic. ”

“Well, I’d never turn down a free massage.”

Audrey scoots closer to Kate and turns her back to her.

“Damn...you are...really good at that.”

Wow...they… look really hot together. Kate’s hands on Audrey…Audrey’s head tipped back, eyes shut…moaning.

My whole body tightens with arousal watching them. Before I realize what I’m saying, it just comes out...

“It would be so hot if you made out...”

“What?”

Fuck, I can’t believe I just said that out loud. Damn. I really hope I didn’t just mess things up between the three of us. Kate and Audrey exchange looks. Audrey’s got that crooked little smile on her face I used to love so much.

“Did…did you just say you want us to make out?”

“Oh, just pretend I didn’t say anything - that was so random, I’m sorry.”

My face is buried in my hands and my cheeks feel hot. The room is silent. I slowly pull my hands away from my face. I’m expecting them to be annoyed...but what I see is Kate’s mouth already pressed up against Audrey’s. Fuck, they look so good together.

Kate pulls away just slightly and motions for me to sit back down on the couch.

“Come here.”

“You’re...you’re both okay with this?”

My body is trembling slightly as I lower myself down on the couch next to Kate.

“Yeah.”

“Yeah, I’m okay with it. I mean, she’s really fucking hot… ”

“Yeah, I’d be lying if I said I hadn’t thought the same about you, Kate.”

“And we both clearly think you’re attractive…”

Kate reaches over and turns my chin towards her. She brings our lips together in a warm, hungry kiss. I feel Audrey’s hand up my thigh. It’s a familiar touch, and my heart races as she rubs me slowly, her touch running up my body until she reaches my hip. I reach down and undo the button of my pants.

Kate’s tongue explores my mouth as Audrey’s hands peel my pants slowly down to my ankles. I kick off my shoes and she tosses my pants to the side. I can’t see exactly what she’s doing, but I feel her settle between my legs. Her hands curl around my hips and her fingers play beneath the waistband of my underwear. Kate’s hand tangles in my hair and she deepens our kiss. Fuck, I love the way she tastes. The way her fingers deftly undo each of the buttons on my shirt. I break her kiss just for a moment to look down at Audrey between my legs. I push my hips up so she can slide my thong off. Her eyes meet mine again as she pushes her mouth between my legs.

“Oh, fuck…”

Her tongue dives deep into my pussy. She licks my clit and her hands curl around the backs of my thighs...Kate’s hands unclip my bra and pull it off. She kisses me again and starts playing with my nipples. She’s so good at making me wet.

I curl my leg around Audrey’s back as she eats me out, drawing her closer, further into me.

“Fuck, keep going…just like that…”

Kate sucks on my nipple, while kneading both my tits with her firm touch...

“Baby, I want to fuck you…”

I put my hand on Kate’s chest and push her down onto the couch. I pull her pants and shoes off while Audrey arranges herself behind me, tossing her jacket and shirt to the floor as I get on all fours on the couch. I press my face into Kate’s pussy...fuck, she’s nice and wet for me. I slide my tongue slowly through her pussy lips...

Behind me, Audrey’s hands slowly slide down my ass. She slides two fingers inside of my pussy...and fucks me with slow, deep thrusts. Oh, god, it feels so fucking good…

I writhe, backing my ass up into Audrey’s fingers as I keep licking Kate’s clit.

“Oh, fuck. Fuck, yeah… ”

Kate’s hands claw at my hair as she fucks my face, riding her hips up and down to bring my tongue deeper and deeper inside of her.

“Baby, yeah… yeah, faster…”

I squeeze Kate’s nipples with both hands, twisting and turning them as I penetrate her with my tongue. God, I love the sounds of her desperate moaning. Her animal pleas for me to fuck her. Audrey’s hand pushes down against my back as she pushes a third finger inside of me. Opening me up, spreading me apart...I pull my mouth away from Kate’s clit for a second, just to breathe and really feel the pleasure of Adurey’s hand going deeper and deeper inside of me. I crawl up Kate’s body so I can kiss her. It’s so hot making her taste her own juices on my lips. I look over my shoulder and Audrey is fingering herself as she fucks me.

“Audrey… will you… will you fuck her?”

Kate nods emphatically as Audrey slides her fingers out of me and I climb off of the couch.

“Yeah…”

“Hold on, I’ll be right back.”

I jog down the hall and into our bedroom. I go straight for the bedside table, grab the dildo in its harness and a bottle of lube, and hurry back out into the living room. Audrey is straddling Kate on the couch, sharing gentle kisses with each other when I hand her the dildo and harness. I put the lube on the coffee table just in case and settle in a nearby armchair to watch.

Kate writhes beneath Audrey, desperate to be fucked. She throws her arms up behind her, drinking in the sight of the dildo being attached to the leather harness.

“Baby, get on all fours. Turn around for her….so you’re facing me.”

Kate glances over at me and grins before obeying. She sweeps her hair off her shoulder and pushes her ass up in the air. Audrey looks so fucking hot with the strap-on hanging from her hips. She soaks the tip in lube before pushing it up against Kate’s ass.

They both look at me like they know they’re putting on a show for my pleasure. It would be rude not to return the favor. I slide my hand between my legs and give my pussy a few long strokes before bringing my attention to my clit.

“You want me to fuck her?”

“Yeah, I want you to fuck her. Fuck her and make her cum all over herself.”

Oh my god, I’m so wet. My clit is so fucking sensitive right now. Audrey curls her body over Kate’s and pushes the dildo slowly inside of her.

“Oh fuck, yes!”

Audrey slowly pulls the dildo until it’s almost out and then thrusts it back in. She picks up speed, rocking forward and back as she fucks my girlfriend.

“Yeah…yeah, just like that. You like that, Kate? You like the way she’s fucking you? ”

“Oh, god, yeah, yeah, I fucking love it. Just like that. Keep going, just like that.”

“Fuck her faster.”

Audrey thrusts in and out of Kate faster and faster while they are both staring at me...I spread a warm rush of wetness up to my clit and fuck myself faster and faster.

“You like that, huh? You like getting fucked from behind, too? ”

Kate’s moans are driving me wild. I fucking love the sound of her pleasure.

“Touch her clit while you fuck her. She loves that.”

I work my fingers faster and faster as heat travels through my whole body as Audrey bends forward to massage Kate’s clit. Fuck, fuck, I’m so close. The two of them together is too much to handle.

“Are you going to cum soon? Cum for me, Kate. ”

I watch as Kate’s whole body jerks and writhes into the couch while Audrey pumps into her a few more times to finish her off. They both collapse onto the couch together.

“So, um…”

“Yeah. Oh! Fuck, Audrey, let Kate and I help you out...”

“No, no, you know I’m more of a giver than a receiver. I’m spent, truly. ”

I get up out of the armchair and sit down next to Kate on the couch. She leans her head into the crook of my neck and kisses me gently.

“That was...unexpected. And amazing.”

“Yeah? You both enjoyed it?”

“Yeah. Absolutely. ”

“God, yes.”

I hold Kate close to me and reach out to take Audrey’s hand. Her fingers intertwine with mine and the three of us just sit there together in a comfortable silence. This will be a Hanukkah I’ll never forget.